SIDS report

33

2.3 MEASURING VULNERABILITY Since the 1990s, SIDS have argued that eligibility for con- cessional finance should reflect their vulnerability to exter- nal shocks rather than income levels alone. This advocacy led to the development of the Multidimensional Vulnerability In- dex (MVI) and, more recently, the Debt Sustainability Support Service (DSSS), launched in 2024 to provide additional analy- sis of SIDS debt burdens. Current thinking has shifted to resilience and how develop- ment partners can help. The OPEC Fund has recognized that SIDS are a special case due to their combination of weak- nesses and vulnerabilities arising from structural factors of low economies of scale, climate change risks, remoteness and environmental risks, amid financing constraints. This has led to the launch of the Island Resilience Facility by the OPEC Fund in May 2025 (details below). While there are many ways to measure vulnerability, most SIDS are consistently more exposed than countries at a sim- ilar income level. SIDS are 35 percent more vulnerable than other developing countries (UNCTAD, 2021), while upper middle income SIDS are 73 percent more vulnerable than countries at a similar income level (OECD, 2018).

MEASURING AND MAPPING VULNERABILITY:

Agreeing on vulnerability measures and how they are used to allocate lending resources is fraught with difficulties, par- ticularly in determining weights of different factors and man- aging “winners and losers” of any possible financing change. 1. The UN, via the work of a high-level panel, developed a new Multidimensional Vulnerability Index (UN MVI, 2024), which covers all LICs and MICs (i.e. not fully SIDS-focused). In August 2024, the UN passed a reso- lution to adopt the MVI set out in a report (UN, 2024), although its use remains voluntary. The UN MVI adds to earlier work including the Commonwealth Universal Vul- nerability Index (FCDO, 2021) and the UN Environmen- tal and Economic Vulnerability Index (UN DESA, 2023), which is currently used as part of the three criteria for inclusion in the LDC category. 2. Building on this work, UNDP took the initiative one stage further and developed a MVI focused only on SIDS (UNDP, 2024, see figure 14, page 35) to reflect traditional as well as emerging risks facing not only SIDS but all de- veloping countries. The MVI is a composite index of four dimensions of vulnerability: environmental, geographic, economic and financial. Using 11 indicators for 128 coun- tries (including 34 SIDS), the MVI demonstrates that all but five SIDS are far more vulnerable than their income level would suggest. Furthermore, a simulation com- paring SIDS to LDCs demonstrates that, if the MVI were used as a financing criterion (rather than just income per capita), SIDS on average would save 1.5 percent of their GDP per annum in interest payments. 3. Meanwhile, while MDBs measure vulnerability, not all use an MVI. For example, the World Bank’s International De- velopment Association has a Small Economies Exception (World Bank, 2022), while the Asian Development Bank uses the UN Economic Vulnerability Index (EVI) (ADB, 2024).

2. SIDS: UNIQUE VULNERABILITIES

Powered by